Key points:
U.S. Small Cap stocks may be in position to benefit from:
Rate cuts: Immediate reduction in interest expenses for small companies reliant on floating-rate loans.
Policy tailwinds: Tariffs, fiscal spending, tax cuts, and deregulation may boost domestic manufacturing and demand.
Historical precedent: Small caps historically lead during economic recoveries and outperform post-junk rallies.
Introduction
Looking solely at index-level returns, U.S. small cap stocks have delivered a relatively positive year. The Russell 2000 Index returned +13.5% through November, a strong return that aligns with historical annualized trends. However, beneath the surface, active management has struggled due to a concurrent ‘junk rally’ that has penalized high-quality companies. Junk rallies lead to significant underperformance of quality characteristics, such as low debt levels, high return on equity, and consistency in earnings year over year - qualities that active managers tend to seek in companies they own. This environment, marked by speculative trading and policy uncertainty, has led to unusual index concentration and underperformance of quality-focused strategies.
Despite the recent experience, we believe current market conditions are set up to deliver strong future total returns in small cap equities and, in our view, are particularly attractive for active portfolio managers.
Macro backdrop favorable for small cap – rate cuts have immediate impact on interest expense for small companies; tariff-related inflation from imports has been lagged but kicking in in coming months
Attractive valuations: small caps are at a historically wide discount to large cap; profitable companies with quality traits are trading at a discount compared to the broader index
Inefficiencies persist: active management historically adds value in small cap given lower analyst coverage; active managers tend to rebound and outperform after periods of strong underperformance